Elementary school · AP US History

The Plymouth harvest feast of 1621: what the painting gets right

Your child is reading The Pilgrims of Plimoth. Marcia Sewall tells the Pilgrims' first years in their own plain words. This painting is the picture most Americans have of the 1621 feast, and much of it is wrong. Here is what really happened.

Ferris's The First Thanksgiving 1621: Pilgrim women hand food to Native men in feathered headdresses sitting on the ground, while a soldier in a metal helmet and Pilgrim men in black hats stand by a log cabin and a table
Jean Leon Gerome Ferris, The First Thanksgiving, 1621, about 1912–1915 (Library of Congress print). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Source and licence

The book your child may be reading

What really happened (Autumn 1621)

The Mayflower reached Plymouth in late 1620 with about 102 passengers. Nearly half of them died in the first winter.

In 1621 the colony made a treaty with Massasoit, the leader of the Wampanoag, whose people had been badly hit by disease. Squanto, a Patuxet man who spoke English, lived among the colonists and helped them.

After the harvest, probably in early October, the 53 surviving colonists held a celebration. Edward Winslow wrote that Massasoit came "with some ninety men," that the feast lasted three days, and that the Wampanoag went out and killed five deer for it.

Nobody called it Thanksgiving then. The colony's first official day of thanksgiving was in 1623, and the 1621 feast was mostly forgotten until Winslow's account was found and reprinted in the 1800s.

What the painting shows

The First Thanksgiving, 1621, by Jean Leon Gerome Ferris, about 1912–1915.

  • In the middle, a Pilgrim woman in a lilac dress hands a dish to Native men sitting on the ground, two of them in tall feathered headdresses.
  • On the right, Pilgrim men in black hats and white collars stand at a table. A soldier in a metal helmet and armour holds a gun, and a log cabin stands behind them.
  • On the left, more colonists and a Native woman stand together with the sea behind. A dog sniffs at the guests in the front.

What is true

  • A harvest feast with Massasoit's men really did happen in 1621, and it went on for days.
  • The armed soldier fits Winslow's account: during the feast the colonists "exercised our arms," showing off their guns.

What was changed or invented

  • The tall feathered headdresses are war bonnets, worn by leaders of the Plains nations far to the west. The Wampanoag did not wear them.
  • The painting has the Pilgrims serving food to Native guests seated on the ground. In the records, about 90 Wampanoag men came, outnumbering the 53 colonists, and they brought five deer to the feast.
  • The log cabin is out of place. Log cabins came to North America later, probably with Finnish and Swedish settlers in New Sweden.
  • Ferris painted it nearly 300 years later as part of a series of 78 scenes from American history. Art historians say his paintings mix real detail with an invented, tidy story.

Short timeline

  1. Sep 6, 1620 · The Mayflower leaves Plymouth, England, with 102 passengers.
  2. Winter 1620–21 · Nearly half of the passengers die.
  3. Mar 22, 1621 · Massasoit and Governor Carver make a treaty of peace; Squanto comes to live with the colonists.
  4. Autumn 1621 · The three-day harvest feast with Massasoit and about 90 Wampanoag men.
  5. 1623 · Plymouth holds its first official day of thanksgiving.

Talk about it: 3 questions

For the dinner table or the classroom.

  1. The Wampanoag brought five deer. Why do you think the painting shows the Pilgrims doing all the serving?
  2. Ferris gave the Wampanoag headdresses from a different part of the country. Where do you think he got his idea of what Native people looked like?
  3. Nearly half the Pilgrims had died that first winter. How might that have changed what the feast meant to the people who were there?

Also worth reading

  • Elementary school

    1621: A New Look at Thanksgiving

    by Catherine O'Neill Grace and Margaret M. Bruchac

    A photo book made with Plimoth Plantation that sets the familiar story beside what the records actually say.

As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Grades come from the school, state and award lists in our database.

Where this fits in school

Sources

More history through paintings

All paintings, by grade and AP course →

Last updated

Find the right books for your child

Pick a grade to see the books schools assign.

Find ReadingList in your Google results more often: