Middle school · AP US History · AP World History

Columbus lands on Guanahani (San Salvador): what the painting gets right

Your child is reading Morning Girl. Michael Dorris tells the story of a Taíno girl and her brother on their island, and the book ends on the morning strangers arrive in boats. This painting hangs in the U.S. Capitol and shows that same morning from the other side. Here is what really happened.

Vanderlyn's Landing of Columbus: Columbus in a red tunic stands on the beach holding a sword and a raised royal banner, his men around him, sailors bending over the sand at left and island people watching from the trees at right
John Vanderlyn, Landing of Columbus, oil on canvas, 1847, U.S. Capitol Rotunda. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Source and licence

The book your child may be reading

What really happened (October 12, 1492)

Columbus's three ships had been out of sight of land for weeks when, early on October 12, 1492, a sailor on the Pinta named Rodrigo de Triana saw land. Columbus later claimed he had seen a light first, and took the reward that had been promised to whoever sighted land.

That morning Columbus went ashore with a royal flag. His two captains carried banners with a green cross and the letters F and Y, for King Ferdinand and Queen Isabel of Spain, who had paid for the voyage.

The island's people, Lucayans, called it Guanahaní. Columbus renamed it San Salvador. Nobody is sure which island in the Bahamas it was; the one named San Salvador today got that name only in 1925.

Columbus believed he had reached the Indies near Asia, so he called the people "Indians." In his account he wrote that they would make good servants. He noticed their gold ear ornaments and took some of them captive to guide him to the source of the gold.

What the painting shows

Landing of Columbus, by John Vanderlyn, 1847.

  • Columbus stands in the middle in a red tunic, bareheaded, holding a sword in one hand and raising a pole with a royal banner of Castile in the other.
  • His officers and soldiers crowd behind him with more banners and spears. One man kneels at his side.
  • On the left, sailors run along the beach and bend over the sand. On the right, island people watch from behind the trees, some bowing low.

What is true

  • Columbus did go ashore that morning carrying a royal flag, and his captains did carry banners for Ferdinand and Isabel.
  • The sailors searching the sand fit Columbus's own account: he noticed the islanders' gold ear ornaments and pressed captives to lead him to the source of the gold.

What was changed or invented

  • The banner is a guess. Columbus's account does not describe the flag. The usual picture shows the banner of Castile, but the royal flag of Ferdinand and Isabel carried the arms of both Castile and Aragon.
  • Vanderlyn painted it in 1847, 355 years later, for the Capitol in Washington. He made it a calm, almost holy moment, with Columbus bareheaded and his hat at his feet. Nobody who was there painted the scene.
  • The islanders hide and bow at the edges, small and in shadow. They are the people Morning Girl is about, and the painting gives them no faces and no voice.

Short timeline

  1. Aug 3, 1492 · Columbus sails from Spain with three ships.
  2. Oct 10, 1492 · Columbus calms a near-mutiny by sailors who want to turn back.
  3. Oct 12, 1492, before dawn · Rodrigo de Triana sights land from the Pinta.
  4. Oct 12, 1492, morning · Columbus lands on Guanahaní and claims it for Spain as San Salvador.
  5. 1847 · Vanderlyn's painting is installed in the U.S. Capitol Rotunda.

Talk about it: 3 questions

For the dinner table or the classroom.

  1. Morning Girl ends with her welcoming the strangers. Knowing what Columbus wrote about her people that same week, how does that ending feel?
  2. The painter put Columbus in the light and the islanders in the shadows. Why would a painting for the U.S. Capitol in 1847 be arranged that way?
  3. Columbus took the reward for seeing land first, even though a sailor saw it. What does that tell you about whose version of a story gets remembered?

Also worth reading

  • Elementary school

    Encounter

    by Jane Yolen

    A picture book in which a Taíno boy watches Columbus land and does not trust the strangers, the same morning seen by a younger child.

As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Grades come from the school, state and award lists in our database.

Where this fits in school

Sources

More history through paintings

All paintings, by grade and AP course →

Last updated

Find the right books for your child

Pick a grade to see the books schools assign.

Find ReadingList in your Google results more often: