Books banned in Montana schools
3 titles removed, restricted or challenged
Few school removals are on record for Montana: 1 in PEN America’s 2021–24 school book-ban index, 2 older documented challenges.
· Updated
All 3 titles, most widely removed first
- The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic SchoolAmazonSonora Reyes · 1 district · removed · latest Mar 2024
- I Know Why the Caged Bird SingsAmazonMaya Angelou · Hamilton High School, Hamilton, 2002 · challenged, kept with an alternate title offered
- The GiverAmazonLois Lowry · Glacier Gateway Elementary, Columbia Falls, 1996 · challenged, kept
“Latest” = the most recent dated removal in PEN America’s 2023–24 index.
Amazon links are affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases.
What people ask about banned books in Montana
- What books are banned in Montana schools?
- 3 titles are on our Montana list, each removed, restricted or challenged by at least one school district. The most widely removed: The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School (1 district · removed), I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings (Hamilton High School, Hamilton, 2002 · challenged, kept with an alternate title offered) and The Giver (Glacier Gateway Elementary, Columbia Falls, 1996 · challenged, kept). The full list is below.
- Is The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School banned in Montana?
- Yes, it is on the Montana list: 1 district · removed. The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School shows every record with its source.
- Is any book banned statewide in Montana?
- None in our records. Every title on this list was removed, restricted or challenged by individual school districts; the label on each title says how many.
3 titles reported as removed, restricted, or formally challenged by at least one Montana school district. This is a state-aggregated view; the specific district and policy vary per title. See each book’s page for its full citation history.
Sources
PEN America’s Index of School Book Bans and the ALA most-challenged list. Montana Department of Education: opi.mt.gov.
3 titles on the Montana list. Type a few letters to check one.
Try it on audio — free. Kids who struggle with the print versions often finish the assigned books by listening.
Listen on Audiblestarts instantlyMany assigned titles are included with an Audible membership; offers vary by account. As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases and membership trials at no extra cost to you.
Each title below shows how far its removal actually reached. Most are decided by a single district and many are still under review, which is not the same as a statewide ban.
How book challenges work in Montana
Montana has 3 titles on file as banned, restricted, or formally challenged by at least one Montana public-school district in the public sources ReadingList aggregates from (PEN America's Index of School Book Bans and the American Library Association's Office for Intellectual Freedom most-challenged list). These tracked numbers represent FORMAL challenges that reached district board minutes, ALA OIF reporting, or PEN America's quarterly index — quieter classroom-level removals that never reached those national trackers are not captured here, so the actual scope of restriction in Montana is plausibly larger than this list reflects.
Book challenges in Montana typically follow a layered process: a parent, board member, or community member files a written request for reconsideration of an assigned title with a specific school or district; the district convenes a review committee (usually comprising teachers, librarians, administrators, and sometimes parent representatives); the committee reads the book, evaluates it against the district's selection criteria and against Montana ELA standards, holds at least one public comment session, and votes to retain, restrict (e.g., grade-level limits or parental consent), or remove the title from the approved curriculum. Decisions are typically appealable to the state board of education within a defined window.
Common challenge bases across the 3 Montana titles tracked here mirror the national pattern: sexual content (most common), LGBTQ+ themes, race and racism, profanity or violence, religion and political content, and depictions of substance abuse. Tracked titles include: The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School; I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings; The Giver. Each title's detail page lists the specific Montana district that initiated the challenge, the date, and (when published) the formal challenge basis recorded in district minutes. For deeper context on national patterns, the linked PEN America and ALA pages publish quarterly and annual reports.
For parents, teachers, librarians, and students in Montana navigating this landscape: the practical paths forward depend on role. Parents who object to a specific assigned title can typically request an alternative assignment from the teacher directly without initiating a formal challenge — most Montana districts have informal opt-out paths well before the formal reconsideration process kicks in. Librarians and teachers facing pressure to remove a title can document the formal selection criteria the book met, gather student-reader testimonials (with FERPA-compliant consent), and align with the National Coalition Against Censorship for advisory support. Students directly affected by a book removal can speak at the school board meeting where the decision is reviewed — public comment is open to all Montana district residents. Montana's Department of Education publishes the formal procedural framework — the source link is in the sources block above.
Download this list: montana.csv (3 titles, with districts and action per title). All states: banned-books-by-state.csv.
Related on ReadingList
- Montana assigned reading lists (all grades)
- Banned books in Texas schools
- All banned and challenged books we track
- Other states where we track school book bans: Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming.
Last updated