Books like The Sherlock Society
Looking for books like The Sherlock Society by James Ponti (Middle Grade Mystery · grades 3–5)? It’s most often read for its themes of mystery, friendship, and courage. The 10 titlesbelow are the closest matches in the ReadingList database — each scored on shared themes, genre, and reading level, and each linked to the curricula, states, and grades where it’s assigned, with primary sources.
These are reading-level matches, not just topical ones — so the picks stay grade-appropriate for a grades 3–5 reader. See how we judge text difficulty on our methodology page.
10 books similar to The Sherlock Society
A Strange Thing Happened in Cherry HallJasmine Warga
The Liars SocietyAlyson Gerber
The Lost LibraryRebecca Stead & Wendy Mass
Goosebumps: Welcome to Dead HouseR.L. Stine
A Mischief of MiceChristie Matheson
DogtownKatherine Applegate & Gennifer Choldenko- Final Word (The Winterton Deception #1)Janet Sumner JohnsonFinal Word (The Winterton Deception #1)Janet Sumner Johnson
Fowl PlayKristin O'Donnell Tubb
Hannah Sharpe, Cartoon DetectiveJanet Tashjian
Impossible CreaturesKatherine Rundell
Get the whole similar-books list in one click
Adds the 10 books with Amazon listings to your cart — keep what you need, remove the rest. Prime shipping where available.
🎧 Prefer audiobooks? Listen free for 30 days with an Audible trial.
As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases and membership trials at no extra cost to you. Prices + availability shown on Amazon.
Why each is a match
- A Strange Thing Happened in Cherry Hallgrades 3–6
- Shares themes of mystery and friendship, same genre (Middle Grade Mystery), and overlapping grades (3–6).
- The Liars Societygrades 3–6
- Shares themes of mystery and friendship, same genre (Middle Grade Mystery), and overlapping grades (3–6).
- The Lost Librarygrades 4–8
- Shares themes of mystery and friendship, same genre (Middle Grade Mystery), and overlapping grades (4–8).
- Goosebumps: Welcome to Dead Housegrades 3–7
- Shares themes of mystery and friendship, same genre (Middle Grade Mystery), and overlapping grades (3–7).
- A Mischief of Micegrades K–3
- Shares themes of mystery and friendship and overlapping grades (K–3).
- Dogtowngrades 3–6
- Shares themes of friendship and courage and overlapping grades (3–6).
- Final Word (The Winterton Deception #1)grades 3–7
- Shares themes of mystery, same genre (Middle Grade Mystery), and overlapping grades (3–7).
- Fowl Playgrades 3–6
- Shares themes of mystery, same genre (Middle Grade Mystery), and overlapping grades (3–6).
- Hannah Sharpe, Cartoon Detectivegrades 3–6
- Shares themes of mystery and friendship and overlapping grades (3–6).
- Impossible Creaturesgrades 4–8
- Shares themes of friendship and courage and overlapping grades (4–8).