
You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye
by Patricia Hermes · Grades 4–6 · Realistic Fiction
You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye by Patricia Hermes is on US reading lists at grades 4–6. It appears on 2 lists: 2 book-award lists, across 2 states. Every citation below links to the primary source.
Free at your library: Libby
Before you buy: Ages 9–11 · Grades 4–6 · 117 pages. The button opens an Amazon search: pick the edition with ISBN 9780590331142 if that is the one your class uses.
Listen on Audiblestarts instantlyPrefer an independent bookstore? Buy it on Bookshop.org →
Audible offers vary by account. As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases and membership trials at no extra cost to you. ReadingList also earns a commission from Bookshop.org purchases, which supports independent bookstores.
Assigned across 2 curriculum lists · 2 states
Grade placement varies by school — the median assigned book spans 4 grade levels (83% span three or more, across 13,258 source-cited assignments).
This page shows where You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye is assigned in US schools — curricula, states, grades, and the primary-source citations behind each placement. Not a summary or study guide.
Reading level at a glance
- Grade range
- Grades 4–6See the list:4th5th6th
- Age range
- Ages 9–11
- Pages
- 117
- Reading time
- about 2h 10m (est.)
- First published
- 1982
- Genre
- Realistic Fiction
- ISBN-13
- 9780590331142
Sources: grade range from the cited lists below, last checked 2026-09-24; pages and year from our catalog record (sources); reading time is an estimate at 250 words a minute.
Good fit for grade 4?
If you have read it with a child or a class in this grade, tell other parents and teachers. One tap, no account.
New to these terms? Reading levels by grade
More formats & details
Other formats on Amazon: Kindle · Audiobook
As an Amazon Associate, ReadingList earns from qualifying purchases and membership trials at no extra cost to you. Pricing, Prime, and trial terms shown on Amazon.
About this book
Book facts and sources (2)
- On award reading lists
- California Young Reader Medal (source: californiayoungreadermedal.org)
- Hawai'i Nēnē Award (source: neneaward.org)
- Catalog record
- First published 1982 · 117 pages (edition lengths vary) (source: how we source book data)
Similar grade-level books
The GiverLois Lowry · 760L
The Hunger GamesSuzanne Collins · 810L
HatchetGary Paulsen · 1020L
Charlotte's WebE.B. White · 680L
See all books like You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye→ — matched on theme + reading level.
Why it is assigned
This realistic fiction title is typically read at grades 4–6. Written in the 1980s; pairs with curriculum units on death and mothers and daughters; cited on 2 lists: 2 book-award lists.
Themes
death · mothers and daughters · cancer · anglais (langue)
Where this book is recommended
California Young Reader Medal
- recommended·3rd grade · Californiasource: California Young Reader Medal past winners, 1987 winner (Middle School/Junior High)
- recommended·4th grade · Californiasource: California Young Reader Medal past winners, 1987 winner (Middle School/Junior High)
- recommended·5th grade · Californiasource: California Young Reader Medal past winners, 1987 winner (Middle School/Junior High)
- recommended·6th grade · Californiasource: California Young Reader Medal past winners, 1987 winner (Middle School/Junior High)
- recommended·7th grade · Californiasource: California Young Reader Medal past winners, 1987 winner (Middle School/Junior High)
- recommended·8th grade · Californiasource: California Young Reader Medal past winners, 1987 winner (Middle School/Junior High)
Hawai'i Nēnē Award
- recommended·4th grade · Hawaiisource: Nēnē Award (Hawai'i) — Hawaii's statewide children's-choice reading program (grades 4-6): students read the annual nominees and vote for their favorite. Winner list verified from the award's published record.
- recommended·5th grade · Hawaiisource: Nēnē Award (Hawai'i) — Hawaii's statewide children's-choice reading program (grades 4-6): students read the annual nominees and vote for their favorite. Winner list verified from the award's published record.
- recommended·6th grade · Hawaiisource: Nēnē Award (Hawai'i) — Hawaii's statewide children's-choice reading program (grades 4-6): students read the annual nominees and vote for their favorite. Winner list verified from the award's published record.
Common questions
- What grade level is You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye?
- You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye is listed for grades 4–6. It appears on 2 state book-award lists across 2 states, which together run from grade 3 to grade 8; the grade band shown above is grades 4–6. Exact placement varies by school and district.
- How long does it take to read You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye?
- It takes about 2h 10m to read You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye (117 pages) at an average adult reading pace of about 250 words per minute — roughly 130 minutes. Faster or slower readers will vary; the estimate is a planning guide for assigning the book.
- What curricula assign You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye?
- You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye appears on reading lists for California Young Reader Medal, Hawai'i Nēnē Award. Each assignment on this site links to its primary-source citation.
- Is You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye banned in schools?
- You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye does not appear in PEN America's Index of School Book Bans 2022-2024. No documented multi-district removals on record, but individual districts may challenge titles locally. See the banned books list by state.
- What themes does You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye explore?
- Central themes in You Shouldn't Have to Say Goodbye include death, mothers and daughters, cancer, anglais (langue).
Why this book is on this list
How we classifyHide
Each dimension below is sourced from a public reference. The full framework is documented on the classification standard page.
- Lexile measure
- Not classified — this book has no published Lexile measure.
- Grade band
- Grades 4–6 — drawn from the state book-award lists citing this book.
- Curriculum alignment
- Cited in 2 curricula on this site (see “Where recommended” above for primary-source links).
- State-level evidence
- On state book-award lists in 2 states (see citations above).
- Removal / banning records
- No tracked removal or challenge records in cited sources.
- Seasonal / contextual tags
- Tagged for: book-club.